On the genesis of the concept of covariant differentiation
Revue d'histoire des mathématiques (1996)
- Volume: 2, Issue: 2, page 215-264
- ISSN: 1262-022X
Access Full Article
topAbstract
topHow to cite
topDell’ Aglio, Luca. "On the genesis of the concept of covariant differentiation." Revue d'histoire des mathématiques 2.2 (1996): 215-264. <http://eudml.org/doc/252048>.
@article{Dell1996,
abstract = {The purpose of this paper is to reconsider the genesis of the concept of covariant differentiation, which is interpreted as arising out of two traditions running through 19th-century research work. While the first tradition, of an algebraic nature, was responsible for the “algorithmic” emergence of the concept, the second, analytical in character, was essentially concerned with the import of covariant differentiation as a broader kind of differentiation. The methodological contrast that these two traditions exhibit, concerning the use of algebraic and variational methods, was mainly evidenced in Ricci-Curbastro’s work, and was a significant factor in the genesis of tensor analysis. The emergence of the notion of covariant differentiation in his research work may, indeed, be interpreted as the resolution of that methodological contrast into the definitive form of a conceptual synthesis.},
author = {Dell’ Aglio, Luca},
journal = {Revue d'histoire des mathématiques},
keywords = {G. Ricci-Curbastro; tensor analysis; covariant derivative; history of},
language = {eng},
number = {2},
pages = {215-264},
publisher = {Société mathématique de France},
title = {On the genesis of the concept of covariant differentiation},
url = {http://eudml.org/doc/252048},
volume = {2},
year = {1996},
}
TY - JOUR
AU - Dell’ Aglio, Luca
TI - On the genesis of the concept of covariant differentiation
JO - Revue d'histoire des mathématiques
PY - 1996
PB - Société mathématique de France
VL - 2
IS - 2
SP - 215
EP - 264
AB - The purpose of this paper is to reconsider the genesis of the concept of covariant differentiation, which is interpreted as arising out of two traditions running through 19th-century research work. While the first tradition, of an algebraic nature, was responsible for the “algorithmic” emergence of the concept, the second, analytical in character, was essentially concerned with the import of covariant differentiation as a broader kind of differentiation. The methodological contrast that these two traditions exhibit, concerning the use of algebraic and variational methods, was mainly evidenced in Ricci-Curbastro’s work, and was a significant factor in the genesis of tensor analysis. The emergence of the notion of covariant differentiation in his research work may, indeed, be interpreted as the resolution of that methodological contrast into the definitive form of a conceptual synthesis.
LA - eng
KW - G. Ricci-Curbastro; tensor analysis; covariant derivative; history of
UR - http://eudml.org/doc/252048
ER -
References
top- [1] Aronhold ( S.) [1863] Ueber eine fundamentale Begründung der Invariantentheorie, Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik, 62 (1863), pp. 281–345.
- [2] Bell ( E.T.) [1945] The development of mathematics, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1945. Zbl0025.00101MR16318
- [3] Beltrami ( E.) [Opere]Opere matematiche, 4 vols., Milano: Ulrico Hoepli, 1902–1920. JFM47.1009.01
- [4] Beltrami ( E.) [1864-1865]Ricerche di analisi applicata alla geometria, Giornale di matematiche, 2 (1864), pp. 267–282, 297–306, 331–339, 355–375, and 3 (1865), pp. 15–22, 33–41, 82–91, 228–240, 311–314; Opere 1, pp. 107–198.
- [5] Beltrami ( E.) [1867a] Intorno ad una trasformazione di variabili, Ibid., 5 (1867), pp. 24–27; Opere 1, pp. 306–309.
- [6] Beltrami ( E.) [1867b] Delle variabili complesse sopra una superficie qualunque, Annali di matematica pura ed applicata, (II) 1 (1867), pp. 329–366; Opere 1, pp. 318–353. JFM01.0209.01
- [7] Beltrami ( E.) [1868a] Sulle proprietà generali delle superficie d’area minima, Memorie dell’Accademia delle scienze dell’Istituto di Bologna, (II) 7 (1868), pp. 411–461; Opere 2, pp. 1–54.
- [8] Beltrami ( E.) [1868b] Sulla teorica generale dei parametri differenziali, Ibid., (II) 8 (1868), pp. 551–590; Opere 2, pp. 74–118. JFM01.0196.03
- [9] Beltrami ( E.) [1880-1882]Sulle equazioni generali dell’elasticità, Ann. mat. pura appli., (II) 10 (1880-1882), pp. 188–211; Opere 3, pp. 383–407. JFM13.0732.01
- [10] Beltrami ( E.) [1884] Sull’uso delle coordinate curvilinee nelle teorie del potenziale e dell’elasticità, Mem. Accad. sci. Ist. Bologna, (IV) 6 (1884), pp. 401–448; Opere 4, pp. 136–179. JFM18.0930.02
- [11] Bertini ( E.) [1892] Commemorazione del Prof. Francesco Casorati, Rendiconti dell’Istituto lombardo di scienze e lettere, (II) 25 (1892), pp. 1206–1236. JFM24.0029.02
- [12] Bottazzini ( U.) [1980] Algebraische Untersuchungen in Italien, 1850–1863, Historia mathematica, 7 (1980), pp. 24–37. Zbl0436.01005MR559833
- [13] Brioschi ( F.) [1854] Teorica dei determinanti, Pavia, 1854.
- [14] Casorati ( F.) [1860–1861]Ricerca fondamentale per lo studio di una certa classe di proprietà delle superficie curve, Ann. mat. pura appli., (I) 3 (1860), pp. 363–379, and (I) 4 (1861), pp. 177–185; Opere, vol. 2, Roma: Cremonese, 1952, pp. 132–163.
- [15] Chelini ( D.) [1853] Sulle formole fondamentali riguardanti la curvatura delle superficie, e delle linee, Annali di scienze, matematiche e fisiche, 4 (1853), pp. 337–394.
- [16] Christoffel ( E.B.) [GMA] Gesammelte mathematische Abhandlungen, 2 vols., Leipzig-Berlin: Teubner, 1910.
- [17] Christoffel ( E.B.) [1868a] Beweis des Fundamentalsatzes der Invariantentheorie, J. reine angew. Math., 68 (1868), pp. 246–252; GMA 1, pp. 269–276.
- [18] Christoffel ( E.B.) [1868b] Theorie der bilinearen Functionen, Ibid., 68 (1868), pp. 253–272; GMA 1, pp. 277–296.
- [19] Christoffel ( E.B.) [1869a] Ueber die Transformation der homogenen Differentialausdrücke zweiten Grades, Ibid., 70 (1869), pp. 46–70; GMA 1, pp. 352–377. JFM02.0128.03
- [20] Christoffel ( E.B.) [1869b] Ueber ein die Transformation homogener Differentialausdrücke zweiten Grades betreffendes Theorem, Ibid., 70 (1869), pp. 241–245; GMA 1, pp. 378–382. JFM02.0129.01
- [21] Codazzi ( D.) [1868] Sulle coordinate curvilinee d’una superficie e dello spazio, Ann. mat. pura appli., (II) 1 (1868), pp. 293–316. JFM01.0212.01
- [22] Darboux ( G.) [1878] Mémoire sur la théorie des coordonnées curvilignes et des systèmes orthogonaux, Annales scientifiques de l’École normale supérieure, (II) 7, pp. 101-150, 227-260, 275-348. JFM10.0500.04
- [23] Ehlers ( J.) [1981] Christoffel’s work on the equivalence problem for Riemannian spaces and its importance for modern field theories of physics, in P.L. Butzer, F. Fehér (eds.), E.B. Christoffel. The influence of his work on mathematics and the physical sciences, Basel: Birkhäuser, 1981, pp. 526-542. Zbl0474.53001MR661094
- [24] Farwell ( R.), Knee ( C.) [1990] The missing link: Riemann’s ‘Commentatio’, differential geometry and tensor analysis, Hist. math., 17 (1990), pp. 223-255. Zbl0743.01017MR1069227
- [25] Frobenius ( G.) [1892] Ueber die in der Theorie der Flächen auftretenden Differentialparameter, J. reine angew. Math., 110 (1892), pp. 1-36. Zbl24.0713.01JFM24.0713.01
- [26] Gauss ( C.F.) [Werke]Werke, 12 vols., Königlichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen ed., Leipzig-Berlin, 1863-1933; repr. Olms, 1981. JFM55.0611.02
- [27] Halphen ( G.) [1878] Sur les invariants différentiels, Thèse, Paris: Gauthier-Villars, 1878.
- [28] Jacobi ( G.) [1847] Über eine particuläre Lösung der partiellen Differentialgleichung , J. reine angew. Math., 36 (1847), pp. 113-134; Gesammelte Werke, vol. II, Berlin, 1882, p. 191-216 (repr. Chelsea, 1969).
- [29] Killing ( W.) [1885] Die Mechanik in den Nicht-Euklidischen Raumformen, J. reine angew. Math., 98 (1885), pp. 1–48. JFM17.0814.03
- [30] Klein ( F.) [1927] Vorlesungen über die Entwicklung der Mathematik im 19. Jahrhundert, vol. II, Berlin: Springer, 1927; repr. Chelsea, 1950. MR529278JFM52.0022.05
- [31] Kline ( M.) [1972] Mathematical thought from ancient to modern times, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1972. Zbl0277.01001MR472307
- [32] Knoblauch ( J.) [1893] Zur Theorie der Differentialparameter, J. reine angew. Math., 111 (1893), pp. 329–343. JFM25.0169.02
- [33] Knoblauch ( J.) [1895] Zur simultanen Transformation quadratischer Differentialformen, Ibid., 115 (1895), pp. 185–200. Zbl26.0308.01JFM26.0308.01
- [34] Koppelman ( E.) [1975] Progress in mathematics, Hist. math., 2 (1975), pp. 457–463. Zbl0339.01001MR479806
- [35] Lamé ( G.) [1834] Mémoire sur les lois de l’équilibre du fluide éthéré, Journal de l’École polytechnique, XIV, 23e cahier (1834), pp. 191–288.
- [36] Lamé ( G.) [1859] Leçons sur les coordonnées curvilignes et leurs diverses applications, Paris, 1859.
- [37] Leichtweiss ( K.) [1981] E.B. Christoffels Einfluss auf die Geometrie, in D. Ferus, W. Kühnel et al. (eds.), Global differential geometry and global analysis, New York-Berlin: Springer (Lecture Notes in Mathematics, 838), pp. 1–11. Zbl0437.53001MR636260
- [38] Levi-Civita ( T.) [Opere]Opere matematiche, 6 vols., Bologna: Zanichelli, 1954–1973. Zbl0074.24102MR62680
- [39] Levi-Civita ( T.) [1893–1894]Sugli invarianti assoluti, Atti dell’Istituto veneto di scienze, lettere ed arti, (VII) 5 (1893–1894), pp. 1447–1523; Opere 1, pp. 41–100.
- [40] Levi-Civita ( T.) [1925] Commemorazione del socio nazionale Prof. G.Ricci-Curbastro, Atti dell’Accademia dei Lincei. Memorie, (VI) 1 (1925), pp. 555–564; Opere 4, pp. 391–402. Zbl52.0031.06JFM52.0031.06
- [41] Lie ( S.) [1884] Über Differentialinvarianten, Mathematische Annalen, 24 (1884), pp. 537–578. MR1510292JFM16.0091.01
- [42] Lipschitz ( R.) [1869] Untersuchungen in Betreff der ganzen homogenen Functionen von Differentialen, J. reine angew. Math., 70 (1869), pp. 71–102. JFM02.0129.02
- [43] Lipschitz ( R.) [1870] Entwickelung einiger Eigenschaften der quadratischen Formen von Differentialen, Ibid., 71 (1870), pp. 274–287, 288–295. JFM02.0130.01
- [44] Lipschitz ( R.) [1871] Fortgesetzte Untersuchungen in Betreff der ganzen homogenen Functionen von Differentialen, Ibid., 72 (1871), pp. 1–56. JFM02.0129.02
- [45] Lipschitz ( R.) [1872] Untersuchung eines Problemes der Variationsrechnung, in welchem das Problem der Mechanik enthalten ist, Ibid., 74 (1872), pp. 116–149. JFM04.0180.01
- [46] Loria ( G.) [1901] Eugenio Beltrami e le sue opere matematiche, Bibliotheca mathematica, (III) 2 (1901), pp. 392–440. JFM32.0017.01
- [47] Lützen ( J.) [1989] The geometrization of analytical mechanics. A pioneering contribution by Joseph Liouville (ca. 1850), in J. Mc Cleary, D.E. Rowe (eds.), The history of modern mathematics, vol. II, Boston: Academic Press, pp. 76–97. MR1037809
- [48] Lützen ( J.) [1995] Interactions between mechanics and differential geometry in the 19th century, Archive for History of Exact Sciences, 47 (1995), pp. 1–72. Zbl0834.01007MR1346355
- [49] Neumann ( C.) [1860] Zur Theorie der Elasticität, J. reine angew. Math., 57 (1860), pp. 281–318.
- [50] Neumann ( C.) [1867] Kurzer Abriss einer Theorie der Kugelfunctionen und Ultrakugelfunctionen, Zeitschrift für Mathematik und Physik, 12 (1867), pp. 97–122.
- [51] Padova ( E.) [1887] Sulle espressioni invariabili, Atti Accad. Lincei Mem., (IV) 4, pp. 4–17. JFM19.0260.01
- [52] Pascal ( E.) [1901] Commemorazione di Eugenio Beltrami, Rc. Ist. lomb. sci. lett., (II) 34 (1901), pp. 57–108. Zbl32.0017.02JFM32.0017.02
- [53] Pinl ( M.) [1981] E.B. Christoffels Weg zum absoluten Differentialkalkül und sein Beitrag zur Theorie des Krümmungstensors, in P.L. Butzer, F. Fehér (eds.), E.B. Christoffel, The influence of his work on mathematics and the physical sciences, Basel: Birkhäuser, 1981, pp. 474–489. Zbl0493.53001MR661089
- [54] Pogrebyssky ( J.B.) [1981] Brill, Alexander Wilhelm von, in Dictionary of scientific biography (C. Gillispie ed.), vol. 1, 1981, p. 465.
- [55] Reich ( K.) [1973] Die Geschichte der Differentialgeometrie von Gauss bis Riemann (1828–1868), Arch. Hist. Exact Sci., 11 (1973), pp. 273–382. Zbl0329.01008MR497714
- [56] Reich ( K.) [1994] Die Entwicklung des Tensorkalküls, Basel: Birkhäuser (Science Networks, Historical Studies, vol. 11), 1994. MR1353442
- [57] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [Opere] Opere, 2 vols., Roma: Cremonese, 1956–1957. Zbl0080.37101
- [58] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1877a] Sopra un sistema di due equazioni differenziali lineari , G. mat., 15 (1877), pp. 135–153; Opere I, pp. 17–39. JFM09.0231.02
- [59] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1877b] ‘Sopra la deduzione di una nuova legge fondamentale di elettrodinamica ...’ — ‘Sopra il modo di agire delle forze pondero-ed elettromotrici fra due conduttori filiformi ’ —, per B. Clausius, Nuovo cimento, (III) 1 (1877), pp. 58–72, 89–106; Opere I, pp. 40–68.
- [60] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1877c] Sulla teoria elettrodinamica di Maxwell, Ibid., (III) 2 (1877), pp. 5–27, 93–116; Opere I, pp. 69–109.
- [61] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1882] Sulla funzione potenziale di conduttori di correnti galvaniche costanti, Atti Ist. veneto sci., (V) 12 (1882), pp. 1025–1048; Opere I, pp. 110–129. JFM14.0886.02
- [62] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1884] Principi di una teoria delle forme differenziali quadratiche, Ann. mat. pura appli., (II) 12 (1884), pp. 135–167; Opere I, pp. 138–171. JFM16.0230.01
- [63] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1886a] Sui parametri e gli invarianti delle forme quadratiche differenziali, Ibid., (II) 14 (1886), pp. 1–11; Opere I, pp. 177–188. JFM18.0102.01
- [64] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1886b] Sui sistemi di integrali indipendenti di una equazione lineare ed omogenea a derivate parziali del 1o ordine, Atti dell’Accademia dei Lincei. Rendiconti, (IV) 2 (1886), pp. 119–122, 190–194; Opere I, pp. 189–198. JFM18.0318.02
- [65] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1887a] Sulla derivazione covariante ad una forma quadratica differenziale, Ibid., (IV) 3 (1887), pp. 15–18; Opere I, pp. 199–203. Zbl19.0128.01JFM19.0260.02
- [66] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1887b] Sui sistemi di integrali indipendenti di una equazione lineare ed omogenea a derivate parziali del 1o ordine, Ann. mat. pura appli., (II) 15 (1887), pp. 127–159; Opere I, pp. 204–238. JFM19.0348.01
- [67] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1888] Delle derivazioni covarianti e controvarianti e del loro uso nella analisi applicata, in Studi editi dall’Università di Padova a commemorare l’ottavo centenario della origine della Università di Bologna, vol. III, Padova, 1888, pp. 3–23 ; Opere I, pp. 245–267. JFM20.0282.01
- [68] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1889] Sopra certi sistemi di funzioni, Atti Accad. Lincei Rc., (IV) 5 (1889), pp. 112–118; Opere I, p. 268–275. JFM21.0423.01
- [69] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1892] Résumé de quelques travaux sur les systèmes variables de fonctions associés à une forme différentielle quadratique, Bulletin des sciences mathématiques, (II) 16 (1892), pp. 167–189 ; Opere I, pp. 288-310. JFM24.0371.02
- [70] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.) [1893] Di alcune applicazioni del calcolo differenziale assoluto alla teoria delle forme differenziali quadratiche binarie e dei sistemi a due variabili, Atti Ist. veneto sci., (VII) 4 (1893), pp. 1336–1364; Opere, I, pp. 311–335. Zbl25.1174.03JFM25.1174.03
- [71] Ricci-Curbastro ( G.), Levi-Civita ( T.) [1901] Méthodes de calcul différentiel absolu et leurs applications, Math. Ann., 54 (1901), pp. 125–201; Ricci-Curbastro, Opere II, pp. 185–271; Levi-Civita Opere 1, pp. 479–559. Zbl31.0297.01JFM31.0297.01
- [72] Riemann ( B.) [Werke]Gesammelte mathematische Werke und wissenschaftlicher Nachlass, (H. Weber ed.), Leipzig: Teubner, 1876; 2nd ed. 1892; repr. New York : Springer, 1991. MR1084595
- [73] Riemann ( B.) [1854] Ueber die Hypothesen, welche der Geometrie zu Grunde liegen, Abhandlungen der Königlichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, 13 (1868), pp. 133–152; Werke, pp. 272–287. Zbl0087.35001JFM01.0022.02
- [74] Riemann ( B.) [1861] Commentatio mathematica, qua respondere tentatur quaestioni ab Illma Academia Parisiensi propositae , Werke, pp. 391–404. English transl. in [Farwell, Knee 1990, pp. 240–253].
- [75] Schering ( E.) [Werke] Gesammelte mathematische Werke von Ernst Schering, R. Haussner and K. Schering (eds.), 2 vols., Berlin: Mayer & Müller, 1902–1909. JFM33.0030.01
- [76] Schering ( E.) [1870] Die Schwerkraft im Gaussischen Raume, Nachrichten von der Gesselschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, (1870), pp. 311–321; Werke 1, pp. 155–162. Zbl02.0688.01JFM02.0688.01
- [77] Schering ( E.) [1873] Die Schwerkraft in mehrfach ausgedehnten Gaussischen und Riemannschen Räumen, Ibid. (1873), pp. 149-159; Werke 1, pp. 177–184. JFM05.0442.02
- [78] Somigliana ( C.) [1890] Sulla trasformazione delle equazioni lineari, omogeneee, a derivate parziali, con coefficienti costanti, Ann. mat. pura appli., (II) 18 (1890), pp. 265–299. Zbl22.0365.02JFM22.0365.02
- [79] Somov ( J.) [1865] Moyen d’exprimer directement en coordonnées curvilignes quelconques, orthogonales et obliques, les paramètres différentiels du premier et du second ordres et la courbure d’une surface, Mémoires de l’Académie des sciences de St-Pétersbourg, (VII) 8 (1865), pp. 1–45.
- [80] Speziali ( P.) [1981] Ricci-Curbastro, Gregorio, in Dictionary of scientific biography, vol. 11, 1981, pp. 406–411.
- [81] Struik ( D.J.) [1933] Outline of a history of differential geometry, Isis, 20 (1933), pp. 161–191. Zbl0007.38806
- [82] Struik ( D.J.) [1981] Beltrami, Eugenio, in Dictionary of scientific biography, vol. 1, 1981, pp. 599–600.
- [83] Tazzioli ( R.) [1993] Ether and theory of elasticity in Beltrami’s work, Arch. Hist. Exact Sci., 45 (1993), pp. 1–37. Zbl0783.01006MR1235863
- [84] Tonelli ( A.) [1882] Sopra la funzione potenziale in uno spazio di dimensioni, Ann. mat. pura appli., 10 (1882), pp. 291–321. JFM14.0797.01
- [85] Tonolo ( A.) [1954] Commemorazione di Gregorio Ricci-Curbastro nel primo centenario della nascita, Rendiconti del Seminario matematico dell’Università di Padova, 23 (1954), pp. 1–24. Zbl0055.00219MR59853
- [86] Tonolo ( A.) [1961] Sulle origini del calcolo di Ricci, Ann. mat. pura appli., (IV) 53 (1961), pp. 189–207. Zbl0103.38406MR122696
- [87] Veblen ( O.) [1927] Invariants of quadratic differential forms, London: Cambridge University Press, 1927. JFM53.0681.01
- [88] Vincensini ( P.) [1972] La géométrie différentielle au XIXe siècle, Scientia, 107 (1972), pp. 616–660.
- [89] Vivanti ( G.) [1935] Felice Casorati nel centenario della nascita, Rendiconti del Seminario matematico e fisico di Milano, 9 (1935), pp. 127–138. Zbl61.0953.09JFM61.0953.09
- [90] Weitzenböck ( R.) [1921] Neuere Arbeiten der algebraischen Invariantentheorie. Differentialinvarianten, in W.F. Meyer., H. Mohrmann (eds.), Encyklopädie der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Leipzig: Teubner, vol. III D, 1902–1927, art. 10, pp. 1–71. JFM48.0517.01
- [91] Weitzenböck ( R.) [1923] Invariantentheorie, Groningen: P. Noordhoff, 1923. JFM50.0070.02
Citations in EuDML Documents
topNotesEmbed ?
topTo embed these notes on your page include the following JavaScript code on your page where you want the notes to appear.